Contemporary Serbian Orthodox church architecture: Architectural competitions since 1990
Abstract
This paper focuses on the architectural competitions for Orthodox Christian churches in Serbia since 1990, both on the analysis of the designs submitted and the competition requirements. The first competition for an Orthodox church in Serbia after World War II was announced for Priština in 1991. After that, competitions for the temple in Čukarica, Novi Beograd, Niš, Aleksinac and Kruševac were conducted. Thanks to the fact that architectural competitions allow a greater degree of creative freedom to the architects than regular practice, various solutions were offered, from replicas of models from architectural history and tradition to fully non-traditional proposals. Depending on the relationship to tradition, architectural design approaches can be classified into three main groups: radically modernizing, conservatively traditionalist, and compromising. Of the six competitions conducted, four churches were built, which are among the most architecturally successful newer churches in Serbia. This points to the importance of the implementation of the architectural competition in this field of architecture. The diversity of the award-winning projects shows that there is awareness of the possibility for the further development of church architecture, favouring a moderate approach.
References
Barbas, C., Tsaggalas, E. (2003) Profaseis en amartiais – Synchroni ellinorthodoxi naodomia – Skepseis kai diapistoseis. Graduation thesis, Aristotelian University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Architecture. http://www.greekarchitects.gr/gr/αρχιτεκτονικες-ματιες/προφασεις-εν-αμαρτιαις-σύγχρονη- ελληνορθόδοξη-ναοδομια-σκέψεις-και-διαπιστώσεις-μερος- b-id686, accessed 20th Oct 2015. [Barbas, C., Tsaggalas, E. (2003) Excuses for Sins. Contemporary Greek-Orthodox Ecclesiastical Architecture. Thoughts and Conclusions. Graduation thesis, Aristotelian University of Thessaloniki, Faculty of Architecture. http://www.greekarchitects.gr/gr/αρχιτεκτονικες-ματιες/προφασεις-εν-αμαρτιαις-σύγχρονη- ελληνορθόδοξη-ναοδομια-σκέψεις-και-διαπιστώσεις-μερος- b-id686, accessed 20th Oct 2015.]
Constitutions (1886) Constitutions of the Holy Apostles, in Roberts, A. and J. Donaldson (eds.), The Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. VII. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, http://www.ccel.org/ccel/schaff/anf07.ix.iii.vii.html, accessed 20th June 2016.
Hrizostom, episkop žički (ed.) (2006) Crkva. Kalendar Srpske pravoslavne patrijaršije za prostu 2006. godinu. Beograd: Sveti arhijerejski sinod SPC. [Hrizostom, Bishop of Žiča (ed.) (2006) Church.Calendar of the Serbian Orthodox Patriarchate for the non-leap year 2006. Beograd: Sveti arhijerejski sinod SPC.]
Fernandez-Cobian, E. (2007) Arquitectura religiosa contemporanea: el estado de la cuestion, in Fernandez- Cobian, E. (ed.), Actas del Congreso Internacional de Arquitectura Religiosa Contempranea, 1: Arquitecturas de lo sagrado: Memoria y proyecto, held 27-29 Sept 2007 in Ourense. A Coruña: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Universidade da Coruña, pp. 8-37. [Fernandez-Cobian, E. (2007) Contemporary religious architecture. The state of art, in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.), Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Contemporary Religious Architecture: Architectures of the Sacred: Memory and Project, held 27-29 Sept 2007 in Ourense. A Coruña: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Universidade da Coruña, pp. 8-37.]
Folić, Lj. (2013) Arhitektura hrama – projektovanje duhovnih objekata. Beograd: Eparhijska radionica za umetničko projektovanje i oblikovanje; Cetinje: Svetigora; Kosovska Mitrovica: Fakultet tehničkih nauka. [Folić, Lj. (2013) Temple architecture: designing spiritual buildings. Beograd: Eparhijska radionica za umetničko projektovanje i oblikovanje; Cetinje: Svetigora; Kosovska Mitrovica: Fakultet tehničkih nauka.]
Ioan, A. (2001) Romanian Orthodox architecture. A retrospect after ten years, Caietele Echinox, No. 1, pp. 187-197.
Jovanović, M. (1987) Srpsko crkveno graditeljstvo i slikarstvo novijeg doba. Beograd: Društvo istoričara umetnosti Srbije; Kragujevac: Kalenić izdavačka ustanova Eparhije šumadijske. [Jovanović, M. (1987) Serbian church architecture and painting in recent times. Beograd: Društvo istoričara umetnosti Srbije; Kragujevac: Kalenić izdavačka ustanova Eparhije šumadijske.]
Jovanović, M. (2007) Srpsko crkveno graditeljstvo i slikarstvo novijeg doba, drugo delimično dopunjeno izdanje. Beograd: Zavod za udžbenike. [Jovanović, M. (2007) Serbian church architecture and painting in recent times, second partially revised edition. Beograd: Zavod za udžbenike.]
Jovanović, Z. (2011) Entre la crisis de criterios y las posibles y nuevas identidades visuales de la arquitectura sacra cristiana. A propósito de una capilla en Bubanj, cerca de Nis, in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Actas del Congreso Internacional de Arcqitectura Religiosa Contemporánea, 2-II: Entre el concepto y la identidad, held 12-14 Nov 2009 in Ourense. A Coruña: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Universidade da Coruña, pp. 40-45. [Jovanović, Z. (2011) Between criteria crisis and possible new visual identities of christian sacral architecture. A purpose of a chapel in Bubanj near Nis, in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Contemporary Religious Architecture: Between Concept and Identity, held 12-14 Nov 2009 in Ourense. A Coruña: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Universidade da Coruña, pp. 40-45.]
Kadijević, A. (2009) Savremeno srpsko crkveno graditeljstvo tokovi, istraživanje i vrednovanje, Novopazarski zbornik, No. 32, pp. 149-163. [Kadijević, A. (2009) Contemporary serbian church building – streams, research and evaluation, Novopazarski zbornik, No. 32, pp. 149-163.]
Kadijević, A. (2010) Tri novije crkve Beograda – tri podsticaja razvoju srpskog sakralnog graditeljstva, Nasleđe, No. XI, pp. 113-133. [Kadijević, A. (2010) Three Recently Built Belgrade Churches: Three Impulses For a Tenable Development of Serbian Religious Architecture, Nasleđe, No. XI, pp. 113-133.]
Kadijević, A. (2013a) Neovizantinizam u arhitekturi Novog Beograda – hram sv. Dimitrija Solunskog (1996-2001), in Rakocija, M. (ed.) Niš i Vizantija, Zbornik radova XI, symposium held 3-5 June 2013 in Niš. Niš: Grad Niš, Univerzitet u Nišu, Pravoslavna eparhija Niška i Niški kulturni centar, pp. 367-374. [Kadijević, A. (2013a) Neo Byzantine style in the architecture of New Belgrade church of St. Demetrius of Thessaloniki (1996-2001), in Rakocija, M. (ed.) Niš and Byzantium, The Collection of Scientific Works XI, symposium held 3-5 June 2013 in Niš. Niš: Grad Niš, Univerzitet u Nišu, Pravoslavna eparhija Niška i Niški kulturni centar, pp. 367-374.]
Kadijević, A. (2013b) Strategije novog srpskog crkvenog graditeljstva i njihov uticaj na neposredno okruženje (1990- 2012), Zbornik seminara za studije moderne umetnosti Filozofskog fakulteta Univerziteta u Beogradu, No. 9, pp. 103-113. [Kadijević, A. (2013b) Strategies of new Serbian church architecture (1990-2012) and their influence on direct environment, Zbornik seminara za studije moderne umetnosti Filozofskog fakulteta Univerziteta u Beogradu, No. 9, pp. 103- 113.]
Kadijević, A. (2015) Srpsko crkveno graditeljstvo (1945-2015) istraživanje i prezentovanje, in Živković, N. (ed.) Arhitektura i urbanizam posle Drugog svetskog rata: zaštita kao proces ili model, zbornik radova sa VI konferencije, held 12th Nov 2015 in Belgrade. Beograd: Zavod za zaštitu spomenika kulture grada Beograda, pp. 157-167. [Kadijević, A. (2015) Serbian ecclesiastical architecture (1945-2015) – research and presentation, in Živković, N. (ed.) Architecture and Urbanism After the World War II: Protection as a Process or a Model, 6th conference Proceedings, held 12th Nov 2015 in Belgrade. Beograd: Zavod za zaštitu spomenika kulture grada Beograda, pp. 157-167.]
Kadijević, A., Pantović, M. (2011) The concepts and identity of the new Serbian orthodox ecclesiastical architecture (1990- 2009), in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Actas del Congreso Internacional de Arcqitectura Religiosa Contemporánea, 2-II: Entre el concepto y la identidad, held 12-14 Nov 2009 in Ourense. A Coruña: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Universidade da Coruña, pp. 30-39. [Kadijević, A., Pantović, M. (2011) The concepts and identity of the new Serbian orthodox ecclesiastical architecture (1990-2009), in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Contemporary Religious Architecture: Between Concept and Identity, held 12-14 Nov 2009 in Ourense. A Coruña: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura – Universidade da Coruña, pp. 30-39.]
Kadijević, A., Pantović, M. (2014) The concepts and identity of the new Serbian orthodox ecclesiastical architecture (1990-2009), in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Between Concept and Identity. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, pp. 119-132.
Manić, B. (2009) Pristup proučavanju novije sakralne arhitekture u Srbiji – analiza mogućnosti razvoja modela pravoslavnog hrama. Magister thesis, University of Belgrade, Faculty of Architecture. [Manić, B. (2009) An Approach to Studying New Sacral Architecture in Serbia – Analysis of the Possibilities for Developing New Orthodox Temple Models. Magister thesis, University of Belgrade, Faculty of Architecture.]
Manić, B., Marić, I., Niković, A. (2013) Can Non Typical Traditional Forms of Sacral Space Serve as a Guide in the Development of New Forms of Religious Architecture in Serbian Orthodox Church?, in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Actas del Congreso Internacional de Arquitectura Religiosa Contemporanea, 3: Mas alla del edificio sacro: arquitectura y evangelizacion, held 14-16 Nov 2013 in Seville. A Coruna: Escuela Tecnica Superior de Arquitectura Universidade da Coruna, pp. 44-51. [Manić, B., Marić, I., Niković, A. (2013) Can Non Typical Traditional Forms of Sacral Space Serve as a Guide in the Development of New Forms of Religious Architecture in Serbian Orthodox Church?, in Fernandez- Cobian, E. (ed.) Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Contemporary Religious Architecture: Beyond the sacred building: architecture and evangelization, held 14-16 Nov 2013 in Seville. A Coruna: Escuela Tecnica Superior de Arquitectura Universidade da Coruna, pp. 44-51.]
Manić, B., Niković, A., Marić, I. (2015a) Odnos tradicionalnih i savremenih elemenata u crkvenoj arhitekturi zemalja zapadnog hrišćanstva u XX veku, Arhitektura i urbanizam, No. 41, pp. 49-62. [Manić, B., Niković, A., Marić, I. (2015a) Relationship Between Traditional and Contemporary Elements in the Church Architecture of Western Christian Countries in the 20th Century, Arhitektura i urbanizam, No. 41, pp. 49-62.]
Manić, B., Niković, A., Marić. I. (2015b) Relationship Between Traditional and Contemporary Elements in the Architecture of Orthodox Churches at the Turn of the Millennium, Facta Universitatis: Series Architecture and Civil Engineering, Vol. 13, No. 3, pp. 283-300.
Marinis, V. (2014) Architecture and Ritual in the Churches of Constantinople. Ninth to Fifteenth Centuries. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Milenković, A. (1996) Architectura: politica ultra. Beograd: Savez arhitekata Srbije.
Milenković, B. (1996a) Dva projekta crkvenih centara, Izgradnja, No. 8, pp. 477-483. [Milenković, B. (1996a) Two designs for church centers, Izgradnja, No. 8, pp. 477-483.]
Milenković, B. (1996b) Morfološke beleške, Glasnik Društva konzervatora Srbije, No. 20, pp. 51-55. [Milenković, B. (1996b) Morhpological notes, Glasnik Društva konzervatora Srbije, No. 20, pp. 51-55.]
Milenković, B. (1996c) Simbol – mesto – forma I, Izgradnja, No. 5, pp. 328-332. [Milenković, B. (1996c) Symbol – place – form I, Izgradnja, No. 5, pp. 328-332.]
Milenković, B. (1996d) Simbol – mesto – forma II, Izgradnja, No. 11, pp. 617-620. [Milenković, B. (1996d) Symbol – place – form II, Izgradnja, No. 11, pp. 617-620.]
Milenković, B. (1997) Kompozicione varijante jednoprostora, Glasnik Društva konzervatora Srbije, No. 21, pp. 40-43. [Milenković, B. (1997) Compositional variants of single space, Glasnik Društva konzervatora Srbije, No. 21, pp. 40-43.]
Milenković, B. (2013) O arhitekturi pravoslavnog hrama, in Folić, Lj. (ed.) Arhitektura hrama: projektovanje duhovnih objekata. Beograd: Eparhijska radionica za umetničko projektovanje i oblikovanje; Cetinje: Svetigora; Kosovska Mitrovica: Fakultet tehničkih nauka. [Milenković, B. (2013) On the architecture of the Orthodox temple, in Folić, Lj. (ed.) Temple architecture: design of spiritual buildings. Beograd: Eparhijska radionica za umetničko projektovanje i oblikovanje; Cetinje: Svetigora; Kosovska Mitrovica: Fakultet tehničkih nauka.]
Milenković, J. (1995) Duhovnost na ispitu, Glasnik Društva konzervatora Srbije, No. 19, pp. 54-56. [Milenković, J. (1995) Spirituality tested, Glasnik Društva konzervatora Srbije, No. 19, pp. 54-56.]
Milovidov, K. (2012) Pochemu u novyh hramov arhaichnaja arhitektura?, Zhurnal “Neskuchnyj sad” , 25 Jan 2012. http://www.nsad.ru/articles/pochemu-u-novyh-hramov-arhaichnaya-arhitektura, accessed 11th Nov 2015. [Milovidov, K. (2012) Why do new temples have archaic architecture?, Journal “Neskuchnyj sad”, 25 Jan 2012. http://www.nsad.ru/articles/pochemu-u-novyh-hramov-arhaichnaya-arhitektura, accessed 11th Nov 2015.]
Mirković, L. (1965) Pravoslavna liturgika ili nauka o bogosluženju pravoslavne istočne crkve. Prvi, opći deo, 2nd facsimile edition. Beograd: Sveti arhijerejski sinod SPC. [Mirković, L. (1965) Orthodox liturgics or the science of Eastern Orthodox Church worship. First, general part, 2nd facsimile edition. Beograd: Sveti arhijerejski sinod SPC.]
Mitrović, V. (2009) Od tradicije do političke korektnosti. Savremeno srpsko crkveno graditeljstvo, DaNS, No. 66, pp. 48-51. [Mitrović, V. (2009) From tradition to political correctness. Contemporary Serbian church architecture, DaNS, No. 66, pp. 48-51.]
Rašković, I., Medar, M. (2003) Konkurs za park i crkvu u Aleksincu, Arhitekt, No. 12, pp. 3-5. [Rašković, I., Medar, M. (2003) Competition for the park and the church in Aleksinac, Arhitekt, No. 12, pp. 3-5.]
Schloeder, S. J. (2014) The Architecture Of The Mystical Body: How To Build Churches After The Second Vatican Council, in Fernandez-Cobian, E. (ed.) Between Concept and Identity. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, pp. 3-27.
Stojkov, B., Manević, Z. (eds.) (1995) Tradicija i savremeno srpsko crkveno graditeljstvo. Beograd: Institut za arhitekturu i urbanizam Srbije. [Stojkov, B. Manević, Z. (eds.) (1995) Tradition and contemporary Serbian church architecture. Beograd: Institut za arhitekturu i urbanizam Srbije [Institute of architecture and urban & spatial planning of Serbia].]
Tuleshkov, N. (2002) Problemi pri obnovyavane na hramovoto stroitelstvo v stranite na iztochna Evropa i v Bulgaria, in Tuleshkov, N. et al. (eds.) Narachnik za pravoslavno hramovo stroitelstvo. Sofia: Arhitekturno izdatelstvo ARH&ART, pp. 51-56. [Tuleshkov, N. (2002) Problems in the revival of church architecture in Eastern European countries and Bulgaria, in Tuleshkov, N. et al. (eds.) Handbook on Orthodox church architecture. Sofia: Arhitekturno izdatelstvo ARH&ART, pp. 51-56.]
Varalis, Y. (2006) Prothesis and Diakonikon: Searching the Original Concept of the Subsidiary Spaces of the Byzantine Sanctuary, in Lidov, A. (ed.) Ierotopija, sozdanie sakral’nyh prostranstv v Vizantii i Drevnej Rusi. Moskva: Progress- Tradicija, pp. 282-298. [Varalis, Y. (2006) Prothesis and Diakonikon: Searching the Original Concept of the Subsidiary Spaces of the Byzantine Sanctuary, in Lidov, A. (ed.) Hierotopy, Creation of Sacred Spaces in Byzantium and Medieval Russia. Moscow: Progress-Tradition, pp. 282-298.]
