A novel method for feasibility testing urban sustainable development policies
Policy making to promote more sustainable development is a complex task due in part to the large number of both stakeholders and potential policies. Policy feasibility testing provides a guide to the viability and practicality of policy implementation and forms an important part of an evidence based policy making process. An extensive literature review has identified no standardized approach to feasibility testing. This paper addresses this knowledge gap by describing a novel method using Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) for feasibility testing of policies aimed at increasing the sustainability of towns and villages in Ireland. Feasibility results are provided for 40 frequently cited policy interventions tested for 18 settlements in Ireland. Policies were selected in the arenas of transport, food, housing and urban form, energy, waste and water. Policies are feasibility tested through analysis of operational evidence from both quantitative and qualitative data sources. Following testing, policies are ranked in terms of feasibility. This research examines the effectiveness of local and national level policies and the importance of both local community involvement and central government regulation in policy success. The inter-settlement variation in feasibility testing scores prioritises policy selection and aims to reduce cherry-picking of policies to support the viewpoints of the decision maker. Although developed for an Irish urban context the methods described here may have applicability elsewhere.
Alvarez-Guerra, M., Viguri, J. R. and Voulvoulis, N. (2009) A multicriteria-based methodology for site prioritisation in sediment management. Environment International, No. 35(6), pp. 920-930.
Bond, A. J. and Morrison-Saunders, A. (2011) Re-evaluating sustainability assessment: aligning the vision and the practice. Environmental Impact Assessment Review, No. 31(1), pp. 1-7.
Brković, M. B. and Milaković, M. (2011) Planning and designing urban places in response to climate and local culture: a case study of Mussafah District in Abu Dhabi. SPATIUM International Review, No. 25, pp. 14-22.
Browne, J., Nizami, A.-S., Thamsiriroj, T. and Murphy, J. D. (2011) Assessing the cost of biofuel production with increasing penetration of the transport fuel market: A case study of gaseous biomethane in Ireland. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, No. 15(9), pp. 4537-4547.
CSO (2011) This is Ireland, highlights from Census 2011, part 1. Dublin: Central Statistics Office Ireland.
Daly, H. E. and Ó'Gallachóir, B. P. (2011) Modelling future private car energy demand in Ireland. Energy Policy, No. 39(12), pp. 7815- 7824.
Druckman, A., Chitnis, M., Sorrell, S. and Jackson, T. (2011) Missing carbon reductions? Exploring rebound and backfire effects in UK households. Energy Policy, No. 39(6), pp. 3572-3581.
EPA (2007) Investigation into why existing environmental technologies are underused, 2005-ET-DS-19-M3. Johnstown Castle, Wexford, Ireland: Environmental Protection Agency.
Fitzgerald, B. G., O’Doherty, T., Moles, R. and O’Regan, B. (2012) A quantitative method for the evaluation of policies to enhance urban sustainability. Ecological Indicators, No. 18, pp. 371-378.
Grimes-Casey, H., Girata, C., Whitefoot, K., Keloeian, G. A., Winebrake, J. J. and Skerlos, S. J. (2011) Product and policy life cycle inventories with market driven demand: an engine selection case study. In: Hesselbach, J. and Herrmann, C., (ed.), Glocalized solutions for sustainability in manufacturing. Heidelberg, Springer, pp. 558-563.
Haas, R. and Biermayr, P. (2000) The rebound effect for space heating empirical evidence from Austria. Energy Policy, No. 28(6-7), pp. 403-410.
Hak, T., Kovanda, J. and Weinzettel, J. (2012) A method to assess the relevance of sustainability indicators: application to the indicator set of the Czech Republic's Sustainable Development Strategy. Ecological Indicators, No. 17(0), pp. 46-57.
Harvey, M. and Pilgrim, S. (2011) The new competition for land: food, energy, and climate change. Food Policy, No. 36, Supplement 1, pp. 40-51.
Jollands, N., Waide, P., Ellis, M., Onoda, T., Laustsen, J., Tanaka, K., de T'Serclaes, P., Barnsley, I., Bradley, R. and Meier, A. (2010) The 25 IEA energy efficiency policy recommendations to the G8 Gleneagles Plan of Action. Energy Policy, No. 38(11), pp. 6409-6418.
Kiker, G. A., Bridges, T. S., Varghese, A., Seager, P. and Linkov, I. (2005) Application of multicriteria decision analysis in environmental decision making. Integrated Environmental Assessment and Management, No. 1(2), pp. 95-108.
Lazarević-Bajec, N. (2011) Integrating climate change adaptation policies in spatial development planning in Serbia - a challenging task ahead. SPATIUM International Review, No. 24, pp. 1-8.
Ledbury, M., Miller, N., Lee, A., Fairman, T. and Clifton, C. (2006) Understanding policy options, Home Office Online Report 06/06, http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/2(6).pdf, (accessed 8th March, 2013).
Lucas, K., Brooks, M., Darnton, A. and Jones, J. E. (2008) Promoting pro-environmental behaviour: existing evidence and policy implications. Environmental Science & Policy, No. 11(5), pp. 456-466.
Macário, R. and Marques, C. F. (2008) Transferability of sustainable urban mobility measures. Research in Transportation Economics, No. 22(1), pp. 146-156.
Moles, R., O'Regan, B. and Morrisey, J. (2008) Environmental sustainability and future settlement patterns in Ireland, http://erc.epa.ie/safer/resource?id=0778ac39-8376-102b-aa08-55a7497570d3, (accessed 8th March 2013).
OECD (2008) Household behaviour and the environment. Reviewing the evidence. Paris: Organization for Co-operation and Development.
Rametsteiner, E., Pülzl, H., Alkan-Olsson, J. and Frederiksen, P. (2011) Sustainability indicator development - science or political negotiation?. Ecological Indicators, No. 11(1), pp. 61-70.
Scott, M. (2010) Regional planning and sustainable development. In: McDonagh, J., Varley, T. and Shortall, S., (ed.). A Living Countryside? The Politics of Sustainable Development in Rural Ireland. Farnham, GB: Ashgate Publishing Ltd, pp. 85-105.
Scott, M. (2012) Planning in the face of crisis. Planning Theory & Practice, No. 13(1), pp. 3-6.
Singh, A., Smyth, B. M. and Murphy, J. D. (2010) A biofuel strategy for Ireland with an emphasis on production of biomethane and minimization of land-take. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, No. 14(1), pp. 277-288.
Sorrell, S., Dimitropoulos, J. and Sommerville, M. (2009) Empirical estimates of the direct rebound effect: A review. Energy Policy, No. 37(4), pp. 1356-1371.
Stupar, A. and Nikezić, Z. (2011) City vs. climate changes - the future and its (un)sustainability: the global applicability of Sarriguren and Jätkäsaari?. SPATIUM International Review, No. 26, pp. 40-44.
Walla, C. and Schneeberger, W. (2008) The optimal size for biogas plants. Biomass and Bioenergy, No. 32(6), pp. 551-557.